Cake Menu
Custom cakes designed to make every celebration feel special
Cake Sizes
All cakes are 2 layers
Want a taller cake / need to serve more people? Add an extra layer for an upcharge!
Round
5” round - serves 5-8 people
starting at $75
6” round - serves 9-12 people
starting at $85
9” round - serves 22-25 people
starting at $115
Square
6” square - serves 10-14 people
starting at $95
9” square - serves 24-28 people
starting at $125
Fillings (+$10)
Cakes are finished with vanilla buttercream at no additional cost unless a filling is selected
Vanilla Custard
Nutella Buttercream
*Cookie Butter Buttercream
*Churro Buttercream
Strawberry Buttercream
Raspberry Buttercream
Cake Flavors
*Vanilla
Chocolate
Confetti
*Churro
*Lemon
Looking for something more custom?
Specialty flavors, shapes, and designs are available upon request — include your ideas in the order form and let’s create something uniquely yours!
I am not joking; I have never had so many people compliment the flavor of a cake! Hands down the BEST cake I’ve ever had
Dessert Menu
Crafted to crave - thoughtfully designed for every celebration.
Dessert Shooters
A Butter Bar favorite; perfectly portioned sweetness for every event big or small
Box of 12 - $60
Flavor Options
*Biscoff Cookie Butter
Cookies & Cream
Double Chocolate
Birthday Cake
*S’mores
Lemon Crumb
Cupcakes
Classic cupcakes finished with vanilla buttercream, customized to complement your theme or cake design
Dozen - $35
Cake Flavors
Chocolate
Vanilla
Churro
Confetti
Lemon
Have a different dessert in mind or spotted something on our socials?
I would love to chat and bring your ideas to life!
